Biblical Studies Carnival XVII
Biblical Studies Carnival XVII is here! Please buckle up, and keep your hands and feet inside the ride at all times!
Biblical Literature
Claude Mariottini offered a number of interesting observations about non-Aaronite priests, including a post on Jesus and Melchizedek and another on David’s sons acting as priests (I offered some reflections on the latter topic myself; I thought I was mostly agreeing with Claude and using his comments as a springboard to make some larger points, but judging by Claude’s response, I must have come off as arguing against Claude’s post, which I never intended).
About the middle of April, Stephen Cook’s attention was drawn to the utopian temple envisioned in Ezekiel 40–48, which prompted a three-post series (here, here, and here) about representations of that visionary temple inside and outside of Ezekiel.
Back on March 19, a convocation on the book of Job was held at the Claremont Graduate Universities. Unfortunately, though I wanted to attend, my schedule would not allow it. Fortunately, Duane Smith was there, and throughout April Duane provided us with summaries of and his reflections on the convocation. Start with his overview of session I, where you will also find links to the other five entries in the series.
This just in! As I was preparing Carnival XVII for posting, John Hobbins posted an argument for including translations of the Hebrew version of Ben Sira in modern study Bibles. I’m eager to see what kind of conversation ensues.
Gary Greenberg graciously gave blog readers some sneak peeks at his book The Judas Brief: see them here, here, here, and here. As far as I know, reviews have not yet started to appear (I know that I’ve been too busy to crack open my own review copy).
David Ker took a look at what he called the “iconography” of the gospels; you need to gloss that as “verbal iconography” to see where David is headed. The complete series unfolds in part 1, part 2, and part 3, with kind of interlude between parts 2 and 3 on “The Doctor’s Strange Omissions” (not “Doctor Strange’s Omniscience,” which is what my brain fooled me into thinking it saw the first time I laid eyes on the title).
If you’ve been following the saga of Michael Pahl’s dissertation, you’ll want to bookmark the post in which he indexes the entire series.
Cognate Literature
If you’re in the mood for an Akkadian letter or four, see Duane Smith’s translations of four tablets from Taanach. Start with his preliminary notes and translation of Taanach 1; this post also contains links to the other three translations.
History and Archaeology
Aren Maeir of Tell-es Safi excavations fame published a brief comment on his own Biblical Archaeology Review editorial in defense of “biblical archaeology.”
Reactions to Simcha Jacobovici’s film The Lost Tomb of Jesus continued to pop up across the blogosphere during April. Todd Bolen links to and discusses a few of the reactions from early April.
Turning to matters of more scholarly merit, April DeConick, Mark Goodacre, and Loren Rosson treated readers to an interesting a provocative discussion of the various so-called “quests for the historical Jesus.” My qualifier “so-called” is important, because it is precisely the labeling of these “quests” that our colleagues examined. Jeffrey Garcia thinks that affirmation of Markan priority leads to problems with such quests; see part 1 and part 2 of his series on Markan “posteriority” (there’s a crude joke lurking in there somewhere).
Methodology
AKMA gave readers a review and critique of Rowan Williams’ Larkin-Stuart Lecture, touching on a number of interesting hermeneutical issues.
The Fifth Birmingham Colloquium on the Textual Criticism of the New Testament received well-deserved attention on the Evangelical Textual Criticism blog. Tommy Wasserman previewed the conference and gave us a sneak peek at his own paper. Peter Head posted some highlights from the first day of the conference, while Tommy commented on the second day (each summary focuses on a single paper of interest).
Philology
Right at the end of the month, John Hobbins began a series reviewing electronic dictionaries of biblical Hebrew; see now part 1, part 2, and part 3.
On more specific topics, Tim Bulkeley debunked the connection of the divine name El Shaddai with breasts.
The Bible in Popular Culture
It was “awards month” over at the Bible Films Blog, where Matt Page treated readers to the Faith and Film Critics Circle Best of 2006 Awards (and a repost of the 2005 awards), Ron Reed’s Top 5 Bible Films, the Arts and Faith Discussion Forum’s Top 100 Spiritually Significant Films, Entertainment Weekly’s Top 12 Film Jesuses, Matt’s own list of the Top Ten Jesus Films, and the Church Times’s list of the Fifty Top Religious Films. As the good book says, “Of the making of lists there is no end.”
Kevin Wilson ventured into politics with two critiques of poor punditry.
Miscellany
As usual, Jim West was the most prolific of the bibliobloggers in April 2007, pointing readers to various bibliographical notices, conferences, awards, and so on. Undoubtedly, however, Jim’s greatest contribution to the blogosphere in April 2007—indeed, his greatest contribution to biblical studies generally—was undoubtedly his coining of the term Bullgeschichte (though I think he misspelled it; shouldn’t it be Bullsgeschichte?). It’s right up there with archaeoporn.
If you’ve ever wondered whether you are a Christian Zionist, you might want to take Bruce Fisk’s diagnostic test.
Airton José da Silva tried to get the biblioblogosphere to cooperate in an Amazon UnSpun ratings venture (see the linked post and then follow the links there). It didn’t quite play out like he intended, I think.
Concluding Unscientific Postscript
I hope you’ve enjoyed this little tour of the biblioblogosphere for April 2007. My sincere apologies to anyone whose posts should have been included, but weren’t. This especially applies to those of you working in New Testament studies, Dead Sea scrolls, and so on—fields in which I don’t keep up with the blog conversations as eagerly as I read those focused on Hebrew Bible studies. In my own defense, I’ll say that I did not receive any nominations this month. Danny Zacharias is slated to host Biblical Studies Carnival XVIII at Deinde in the first week of June 2007; please make Danny’s life a little easier by sending your nominations (see the carnival home page for details).
The conclusion of the matter: all has been said. Well, until next month, anyway.
16 comments Christopher Heard | blogging

Chris, great job.
I did a bad, bad thing! Because of some boring problems, the link to my Taanach series should now be http://www.telecomtally.com/blog/2007/04/taanach_1_a_letter_from_ehlite.html. The one you used no longer exists. Sorry.
[...] Heard at Higgaion has this month’s Biblical Studies Blog Carnival up and running. Since Chris leads towards the Hebrew Bible side of things, the roundup is heavy [...]
Biblical Studies Carnival XVII is Up…
Chris Heard, at Higgion, has done a great job pulling together the most interesting of last month’s posts. The collected posts represent the best of the academic study of the Bible on the web. Go over to Chris’ place and……
Don’t people usually start to submit posts on the first of the month, with about a week to allow people to get submissions in? That’s what I seem to remember from previous carnivals.
[...] Today I came across this argument for incorporating the Hebrew version of Sirach (Ecclesiasticus) in study bibles. (Hat tip to Higgaion). [...]
Really a great job, Chris. I can understand your slight frustration with the lack of suggestions. When I hosted I received 2 useful suggestions and that was it. And both were from Tyler Williams! I agree with you, folk should send along offerings.
Best,
J
Jeremy, in recent history at least, the carnivals have tended to go up on the 1st of the month, thus necessitating a bit more lead-in for submissions.
Great Job, Chris! Your post was very helpful, since I hardly read many blogs in April.
Thanks so much, Chris! —Stephen Cook
The other factor may be that some blogs give plugs for people to submit posts. I know Tyler usually does this, and Mark Goodacre often does. I read both their blogs, and I didn’t see a reminder this time around, at least not in the last several days.
I didn’t realize that the submissions have been really low as a general practice. Most carnivals are entirely dependent on people’s submissions of their own material. The philosophy carnival has very little of hosts including their favorites, and the Christian Carnival usually has none of that. The original carnival was the Carnival of the Vanities, and that was entirely submission-based. I was just assuming that most carnival posts have been from people submitting their own stuff.
Hey Chris, don’t know if you’ll get back to this, but have you heard of “the Jesus Project” that the Center for Inquiry is sponsoring? It’s basically supposed to be like the Jesus Seminar but focusing on the question: Did Jesus Exist? As a biblical scholar, how often do you come across the notion that Jesus never existed? Also, how likely is it that such a series of conferences is to change anyone’s views?
Since you mentioned our posts on the Fifth Birmingham Colloquium on Textual Criticism I can add that there will be some more posts on the subject soon. Also at http://www.itsee.bham.ac.uk the organizers have uploaded some of my and Hugh Houghton’s pictures: http://www.itsee.bham.ac.uk/conferences/5CollPics.htm
[...] page is under construction!” Also, Cruv gave me a plug at his blog To Tell You The Truth. And I also got a mention on this month’s Biblical Studies Carnival (Only because I begged Chris to put me [...]
[...] Heard has uploaded Biblical Studies Carnival XVII over at his blog, Higgaion. Chris has done an excellent job highlighting the best of biblical [...]
[...] Heard at Higgaion has posted the latest installment in the Biblical Studies Carnival. Go take a look, if you’re interested in seeing some of the best things posted on academic [...]
Thanks to your reference, Doug Chapin of MetaCatholic picked up on my post on Ben Sira. I continue the conversation in a subsequent post. You might enjoy checking it out.